From Dividends to a Portfolio Paycheque

Justin D. Caldwell - Jul 15, 2026

Tanya completes the Conduct and Practices Handbook course, and why your withdrawal plan — not dividend yield — should drive portfolio construction.

Steady Gains #11 · July 2026

This month, we explore a more flexible approach to creating retirement income and celebrate Tanya’s CPH achievement.

For many investors, dividends feel different from the rest of a portfolio’s return. They arrive as cash, are easy to see, and can create the impression that income has been earned without touching the original investment.

That distinction is less meaningful than it appears.

A dividend is part of your return

When a company pays a dividend, cash leaves the business and is transferred to shareholders. The share price typically falls by roughly the amount paid.

Average dividend of US$0.76 per share and ex-dividend-date share price decline of US$0.79 for the top 100 S&P 500 dividend payers, 2021–2023. Source: FactSet.

This does not make dividends undesirable. It simply means they are one component of total return, alongside interest and capital appreciation.

Focusing too heavily on dividends can also narrow a portfolio. Many companies reinvest profits, repurchase shares, or do not pay dividends at all. In Canada, a dividend-focused approach can create greater exposure to a small number of sectors, including banks, pipelines, and utilities.

Buybacks as a share of cash returned to shareholders: United States 60%, Canada 47%, Japan 42%, UK 36%, EU 29%, and global 34%.

Our goal is not to produce the highest possible yield. It is to build a diversified portfolio capable of supporting your spending needs through multiple sources of return.

Creating a portfolio paycheque

Retirement income does not need to depend on whichever investments happen to pay the largest dividends.

A portfolio paycheque starts with the household’s actual spending requirement. Cash may come from available reserves or from investments that have appreciated and moved above their target weight. An investment that has recently declined may be left intact, provided it continues to serve its intended role. Taxes, account structure, and the broader financial plan are considered at each step.

Illustrative portfolio withdrawal: Asset A, down 15%, is left intact; Asset B, up 8%, is sold for cash. Not actual portfolio results.

This approach works alongside rebalancing. It can reduce the need to sell assets after a period of weakness, keep the portfolio aligned with its risk target, and adapt as markets and spending needs change.

Dividends follow a company’s payout schedule. A portfolio paycheque can be adjusted to the investor’s needs.

The takeaway

Your spending needs should determine your withdrawal plan. Dividend yield should not drive portfolio construction.

A total-return approach provides greater flexibility to diversify broadly, manage risk, and create a planned source of cash flow without requiring every investment to produce income in the same way.


Investing in Our Team

Tanya Siripala of Caldwell Group.

This month, Tanya successfully completed the Conduct and Practices Handbook course. Together with her Canadian Securities Course credential, this strengthens her knowledge of Canadian securities regulation, compliance standards, and professional conduct.

For our practice, this adds further depth to the support behind account administration, trade execution, and the high standard of care we bring to managing your financial affairs.

Please join us in congratulating Tanya on this important achievement.


The opinions expressed in this report are the opinions of the author and readers should not assume they reflect the opinions or recommendations of Richardson Wealth Limited or its affiliates. Assumptions, opinions and estimates constitute the author’s judgment as of the date of this material and are subject to change without notice. We do not warrant the completeness or accuracy of this material, and it should not be relied upon as such. Before acting on any recommendation, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and, if necessary, seek professional advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Insurance Services are offered through Richardson Wealth Insurance Services Limited (RWISL) in BC, AB, SK, MB, NWT, ON, QC, NB, NS, NL and PEI. Insurance products are not covered by the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF). RWISL is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Richardson Wealth Limited (RWL). RWL is a subsidiary of iA Financial Corporation Inc. and is not affiliated with James Richardson & Sons, Limited (JRSL). Richardson Wealth is a trademark of JRSL and RWL and its subsidiaries are licensed users of the mark. RWL is a member of CIPF.